South African court hears ANC challenge over candidate list
The ANC is seeking to get 181 excluded candidates back on the ballot for the local elections.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
South Africa's Constitutional Court will hear the ANC's appeal on Monday against the exclusion of 181 candidates. The case turns on whether uploading candidate details without a final confirmation was legally sufficient.
The ANC lost the case at the Electoral Court and has now taken the dispute to South Africa's highest court. The party wants its candidates to be allowed to contest the local elections on 4 November.
The 181 candidates were excluded in six municipalities. They are candidates on lists for municipalities in the Eastern Cape and KwaZulu-Natal, and for the metropolitan municipality of Mangaung in the Free State province.
The heart of the dispute is a digital action. According to the electoral commission, the IEC, parties must finally submit their lists after uploading them by clicking the 'submit as final' button. The ANC says entering the data was already sufficient to show that the candidates had been nominated.
The IEC argues that the statutory procedure and deadline must be applied equally to all parties. The Democratic Alliance, which has intervened in the case, also warns that an exception would undermine the rules governing political participation.
The electoral commission previously said that 45 parties had entered data for a total of 2,274 candidates but had not submitted it finally. The ANC dispute is therefore part of a broader problem with digital candidate registration, although only the ANC appeal is before the Constitutional Court on Monday.
The ruling could affect the ballot papers and the election timetable. For South African voters, the case concerns not only a software step but also how strictly election rules should be applied when a major party says its candidates were entered on time.
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- The ANC has appealed against the exclusion of 181 candidates.
- The IEC says final submission before the deadline was required.
- The Constitutional Court is hearing the case on 12 October.
Left
Arguments The court should prevent voters from losing their political choice because of a digital procedural error, particularly if candidate details were demonstrably entered on time.
Values Political participation, inclusivity and protection against exclusion.
Consequences A broad interpretation could give more voters access to their preferred list, but could also reduce the predictability of deadlines.
Centre
Arguments The Court should assess the statutory wording, how the system operated and the consequences for all parties together, without disrupting the election timetable.
Values Legal certainty, equal treatment and institutional stability.
Consequences A limited, well-reasoned ruling could protect both participation and practicality.
Right
Arguments Election deadlines have meaning only if they are applied strictly and equally to everyone; a major party should not be given preferential treatment.
Values Consistency in applying rules, accountability and confidence in the electoral administration.
Consequences Allowing candidates in retrospect could disadvantage other parties and make future procedures less reliable.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The date of the hearing, the number of candidates and the legal core of the dispute have been confirmed by the Constitutional Court and Eyewitness News. The article describes ongoing proceedings and makes no statement about the outcome.
- confirmed The Constitutional Court is hearing the ANC case on 12 October 2026. — The case is on the Court's official agenda. source
- confirmed The ANC wants 181 candidates in six municipalities to be allowed to take part after all. — Described by Eyewitness News. source
- confirmed The local elections are scheduled for 4 November. — Mentioned in Eyewitness News's current report. source
- confirmed The dispute centres on the button for final submission. — Eyewitness News describes this as the legal core of the case. source
- confirmed 45 parties had entered data for 2,274 candidates without making a final submission. — This figure appears in Eyewitness News's current report. source
Editor's note
The hearing and the background to the dispute have been confirmed. No ruling was available at the time of publication.Sources
- Forthcoming Hearings — Constitutional Court of South Africa
- ANC takes fight with IEC over candidates list debacle to ConCourt — Eyewitness News
- IEC believes the ANC’s case has little prospects of success — Eyewitness News
More on this in Dutch media
- Het Parool — „zuid-afrika anc”
- Trouw — „zuid-afrika anc”
- NRC — „zuid-afrika anc”