Roblox accused of downloading 3D models on a large scale
An administrator of three model websites says a crawler retrieved 145.5 gigabytes of files, but Roblox has not confirmed this.
A crawler identifying itself as Roblox reportedly downloaded 145.5 gigabytes of models, according to the administrator of three 3D websites. The claim has not been independently confirmed, and Roblox has reportedly not responded to the administrator.
The sites Open3DLab, SFMLab and SmutBase say the crawler searched almost their entire catalogues on 15 and 16 October. According to their log data, 1,027 files from 712 projects were retrieved.
The crawler used a user agent containing the text ‘trellis2-data-sourcing’, a reference to 3D research and a Roblox email address. The administrator says the crawler operated from a single Amazon Web Services address and ignored the robots.txt rules and terms of use.
The administrator suspects that the files were collected for the training or evaluation of a 3D model. This has not been established. It is also unknown whether the data was actually used in a model.
Of the downloaded projects, 423 reportedly had a non-commercial licence. The websites say they blocked the crawler and asked Roblox for an explanation twice.
Without a response from Roblox or independent verification of the log files, the attribution remains uncertain for now. The case does, however, touch on a broader debate about consent, licences and the collection of digital works for generative AI.
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- According to the administrators of three websites, a crawler retrieved large quantities of 3D files.
- The crawler used a user agent referring to Roblox.
- According to the administrators, Roblox has not confirmed its involvement.
- Some of the files reportedly had licences permitting non-commercial use.
Left
Arguments Digital creators should retain control over how their work is used; platforms with substantial resources should not quietly collect material for AI.
Values Copyright, equality of power and protection of creators.
Consequences Stricter consent requirements could slow AI development, but would prevent creators from being presented with a fait accompli afterwards.
Centre
Arguments Clear rules are needed for transparency, opt-out and verifiable licences, without making legitimate research impossible.
Values Legal certainty, innovation and proportionality.
Consequences A verifiable registration system could reduce conflicts, but would require additional oversight and administration.
Right
Arguments Publicly available files are not automatically freely available for every purpose, but companies must also be able to experiment without obtaining prior permission for every data point.
Values Innovation, property rights and limited regulatory burdens.
Consequences Overly burdensome rules could put European developers at a disadvantage; too few rules could undermine trust in AI.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved with corrections · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The reported downloads and technical details come from a single first-hand source and were only summarised by a second publication. The text therefore explicitly presents Roblox’s involvement and the AI purpose as unconfirmed claims.
- uncertain 145.5 gigabytes of files were downloaded. — Based solely on Open3DLab’s log analysis. source
- uncertain The crawler was operated by Roblox. — The user agent mentions Roblox, but this is not independent confirmation. source
- uncertain The data was intended for AI training. — This is the website administrator’s suspicion, based on the user agent. source
1 correction(s) applied
- Was: Roblox accused of downloading 3D models on a large scaleNow: Roblox accused of downloading 3D models on a large scale (The headline has been retained, but the text makes the accusation explicit and does not confirm it as fact.)