Italian Court of Cassation to revisit Eternit case
Italy’s highest criminal court is today hearing the appeal against entrepreneur Stephan Schmidheiny’s conviction.
The Italian public prosecutor has asked the Court of Cassation to uphold Stephan Schmidheiny’s conviction in the Eternit case. The case concerns the deaths of 91 people, which earlier judges linked to exposure to asbestos around the factory in Casale Monferrato.
The hearing will take place in Rome on Tuesday. According to Italian media, a nine-year-and-six-month sentence is at the centre of the case. The prosecutor is asking the highest criminal court to uphold that ruling.
Schmidheiny was an executive at the Swiss Eternit group, which produced asbestos cement products in Italy. The criminal case concerns deaths in and around Casale Monferrato, where an Eternit factory operated for many years.
The current proceedings are the latest chapter in a lengthy legal process. Earlier rulings have been quashed or referred back several times in Italy, partly because of legal questions about the charge brought and the way individual deaths were linked to personal responsibility.
The case is therefore not only a judgment on one entrepreneur. It also concerns how courts should legally assess long-term health damage caused by industrial exposure when victims die over many years.
According to RaiNews, the Italian public prosecutor has argued for the existing conviction to be upheld. That is the position of the Public Prosecution Service; the Court of Cassation must still decide whether the ruling can stand in law.
For Dutch readers, the case is particularly relevant as a European precedent for liability following asbestos exposure. The sources report no direct consequences for Dutch proceedings. At the time of publication, the Court of Cassation had also not yet issued a final decision.
Also show where in Europe and in the world
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- Italy’s Court of Cassation is hearing the appeal in the Eternit case.
- The public prosecutor is seeking confirmation of a nine-year-and-six-month conviction.
- The case concerns deaths that, according to earlier rulings, are linked to asbestos exposure around Casale Monferrato.
- At the time of publication, no final decision by the Court of Cassation was available.
Left
Arguments The case shows that victims of industrial pollution need effective access to justice and recognition of collective responsibility.
Values Health, worker protection and equal legal protection carry significant weight.
Consequences Upholding the conviction could give relatives recognition and make companies more accountable for long-term health risks.
Centre
Arguments The court must carefully examine individual responsibility and the evidence, precisely because the exposure and deaths were spread over many years.
Values Legal certainty, an independent judiciary and a fair trial are central.
Consequences A legally sound ruling could provide guidance for similar cases without liability being assumed automatically.
Right
Arguments Criminal law should not be used to punish corporate decisions retrospectively when causation and personal responsibility have not been sufficiently established.
Values Individual guilt, predictable rules and state restraint are important.
Consequences Quashing or referring the case back could emphasise that public outrage must not take the place of legal evidence.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The proceedings, the person involved, the substance of the charges and the public prosecutor’s request were confirmed by two public Italian news sources. The text makes clear that a final ruling was not yet known.
- confirmed Italy’s Court of Cassation is hearing the Eternit case on 10 November 2026. — Mentioned by La Stampa and RaiNews. source
- confirmed The public prosecutor is seeking confirmation of a nine-year-and-six-month conviction. — Reported by both sources consulted. source
- confirmed The case concerns 91 deaths linked to asbestos exposure around Casale Monferrato. — La Stampa describes the appellate conviction as relating to 91 manslaughter cases. source
- confirmed Schmidheiny was an executive at the Swiss Eternit group. — The sources describe him as a former executive or entrepreneur behind Eternit. source
Editor's note
It is certain that Italy’s Court of Cassation will hear the case on 10 November and that the public prosecutor is seeking confirmation of the conviction. A final ruling had not yet been established in the sources used.Sources
More on this in Dutch media
- Het Parool — „eternit asbest”
- Trouw — „eternit asbest”
- NRC — „eternit asbest”