Google admits error over sensitive adverts
A software error could show adverts for almost three years that, under Google's own policy, should not have been personalised.
Google has acknowledged in a US court case that an error in its advertising platform could allow sensitive adverts to appear for almost three years. MediaPost bases its report on court documents. It remains unclear how many users were affected and what the consequences for them are.
According to the court documents, the error was introduced in July 2019. Google discovered the problem in April 2022 during a joint review by its ad safety and trust and safety teams, after which the company says it fixed the error on 23 May 2022.
According to Google, the error occurred only in certain cases involving display adverts. Advertisers had to use Optimized Targeting or Custom Segments, while under Google's policy the advert should have been restricted from personalised advertising.
Google gives the example that adverts from a personal injury lawyer could nevertheless appear to users. In the documents cited, the company does not explain why such adverts were classified as sensitive in the case concerned.
The disclosure emerged from a privacy case in which internet users claim that Google collected health information from websites for personalised adverts. Google does not say that all adverts of this type were shown and reports that several other forms of remarketing were not affected by the error, according to the statement.
The number of affected users and adverts shown is unknown. Nor has it been established that Dutch users were affected. It therefore remains unclear how significant the practical impact is and whether the information will have consequences for European regulatory cases.
Also show the region and a close-up
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- Google says a software error could allow certain restricted advert categories through.
- According to Google, the error was discovered and fixed in 2022.
- The available source contains no figure for the number of affected users.
Left
Arguments Platform companies should be demonstrably responsible for the consequences of errors in systems that affect sensitive information and groups, with far-reaching transparency and oversight.
Values Privacy, protection of vulnerable users and public accountability.
Consequences Without stricter controls, users may find it difficult to know what profiling is taking place; stricter rules could limit the advertising market.
Centre
Arguments The error should be investigated through the court case and independent regulators, distinguishing between a limited technical error and structural abuse.
Values Evidence, proportionality and enforceable rules.
Consequences A precise delineation could make redress and compensation possible without banning all personalised adverts in advance.
Right
Arguments Companies should be held accountable for errors, but new rules should not unnecessarily block innovation or companies' ability to show relevant adverts.
Values Responsibility, business freedom and limited government intervention.
Consequences Overly broad regulation could affect advertising revenues and smaller advertisers; targeted enforcement could limit the same risk.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved with corrections · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The technical error, the period and Google's own explanation can be found in the source used. Claims about numbers, Dutch users and European consequences are presented as unknown.
- confirmed The error was introduced in July 2019 and fixed in May 2022. — MediaPost quotes Google's court documents giving these dates. source
- confirmed The error concerned certain display adverts using Optimized Targeting or Custom Segments. — This appears in the statement by a Google engineer cited by MediaPost. source
- confirmed The number of affected users is unknown. — The source used gives no figure; no number has therefore been included in the article. source
1 correction(s) applied
- Was: Google showed sensitive adverts to users.Now: Google acknowledged that an error could allow sensitive adverts to appear. (The source confirms the possibility and the position presented in court, but gives no full scale or finding covering all users.)
Editor's note
Google's admission appears in a recent court filing and was described by MediaPost. Within the search budget, no second independent source was found confirming the scale, European consequences or exact court documents.Sources
- Google Glitch Served 'Sensitive Ads' To Users — MediaPost
More on this in Dutch media
- Het Parool — „google advertenties”
- NRC — „google advertenties”
- Tweakers — „google advertenties”