Belgium seeks to deny accommodation to some asylum seekers
The measure targets people who have already applied for asylum in another EU member state.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
Belgium wants to deny certain asylum seekers who previously applied for protection in another EU member state the right to accommodation in Belgium if that other member state is responsible for their application. The proposal forms part of the implementation of the European migration and asylum pact.
Belgium’s federal ministers have approved a bill intended to transpose the new European reception directive into national law. The measure targets so-called Dublin asylum seekers: people who first arrived in another EU member state and began an asylum procedure there, but then applied for protection again in Belgium.
According to Minister for Asylum and Migration Anneleen Van Bossuyt, these applications account for about 38 per cent of all requests for international protection in Belgium. The Belgian government says that, in principle, the first member state of arrival is responsible for processing the application.
If the Belgian authorities establish that another member state is responsible, they may refuse accommodation in a regular reception centre. Those concerned would have to return to the responsible member state and await the procedure there. Specialised return centres exist for such transfers, including in Zaventem and, soon, near Ghent.
The government presents the measure as a way to limit repeated procedures and pressure on Belgium’s reception network. Van Bossuyt says asylum seekers should not be able to start a new procedure in another European country each time while again requesting accommodation.
Critics question whether the measure takes sufficient account of the circumstances in which people travel through Europe. Vluchtelingenwerk Vlaanderen points out that reception, recognition rates and access to social rights differ from country to country. According to the organisation, movement may therefore also be linked to safety or the way someone is treated in a first country.
The precise legal implementation is not yet final. The bill must go through the rest of the legislative process and must be compatible with European law and the individual right to an asylum procedure. It is also not yet clear how many people would actually lose access to accommodation.
The development is relevant to the Netherlands because Belgium is a neighbouring country and EU partner, and because the measure affects the operation of the Dublin system. The decision does not automatically change Dutch reception rules, but it could have consequences for cross-border transfers and the distribution of reception pressure within Europe.
Also show where in Europe and in the world
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- Belgium’s federal government has approved a bill concerning accommodation for certain asylum seekers.
- The proposal targets people who have already begun a procedure in another EU member state.
- The final law and legal review have not yet been completed.
Left
Arguments Accommodation is a basic condition for a fair procedure; people should not be left without shelter because European systems operate unequally.
Values Human dignity, protection and access to legal assistance.
Consequences Refusing accommodation can cause homelessness, health problems and poorer access to the procedure.
Centre
Arguments The Dublin system works only if member states actually fulfil their responsibilities, but every measure must be individually reviewable and legally sustainable.
Values The rule of law, practicability and European cooperation.
Consequences A targeted measure can reduce pressure on reception facilities, but only if transfers take place in a practical and safe manner.
Right
Arguments Anyone who already has a procedure under way in another member state should not be able to claim accommodation and treatment in Belgium repeatedly.
Values Borders, rules and the manageability of migration.
Consequences The measure may discourage secondary migration and free up capacity for first applications.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The text is based on recent reporting about the Belgian bill and on explanations by the minister concerned. The legal consequences are phrased cautiously because the law is not yet final.
- confirmed Belgium wants to refuse accommodation to certain Dublin asylum seekers. — Reported by The Brussels Times and BelgiumNow. source
- confirmed According to the minister, Dublin asylum seekers account for about 38 per cent of applications in Belgium. — Attributed to Minister Van Bossuyt. source
- confirmed The measure is not yet a definitive law. — The sources refer to a draft or approved bill. source
Editor's note
The federal approval of the bill has been confirmed; the final law and legal review have not yet been completed. The figure of 38 per cent is an estimate by the Belgian minister.Sources
More on this in Dutch media
- de Volkskrant — „belgië asiel”
- RTL Nieuws — „belgië asiel”
- NOS — „belgië asiel”