European pesticides named in 1,605 Brazilian reports
An investigation links the reports to products made by European companies, but registration does not prove that a product caused the poisoning.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
Pesticides made by European chemical companies were named last year in 1,605 Brazilian reports of possible poisoning. Around a third of those reports concerned substances that may not be used on farms in the European Union.
The figures come from an analysis of data from Brazil’s Ministry of Health by investigative organisations Unearthed and Public Eye. More than 6,700 medical reports concerning agricultural pesticides were registered last year. A recognisable agricultural product was named in 2,857 reports; 1,605 of those referred to brands made by European pesticide companies.
The registration must be read carefully. Brazilian healthcare providers are required to report suspected or confirmed exposure. Of the 2,857 reports involving a recognisable product, 1,420 were classified as confirmed poisoning and 1,108 as exposure. The remaining reports received another or an unknown classification.
A product name in a report therefore does not prove that the product was the cause. Laboratory confirmation is rare, according to the reporting, and the classification is often based on clinical assessment. Manufacturers Syngenta and Bayer therefore question whether all products and exposures were reliably identified.
The analysis mentions Reglone, among other products, a diquat-based product that may no longer be used on farms in the European Union since 2019. Reglone was named 44 times, including in four reports involving a death. In 26 of those reports, the poisoning was registered as confirmed; the remaining cases received another classification.
Dormex, a cyanamide-based product, also appears in the analysis. Cyanamide was no longer authorised in the European Union in 2008 because of concerns about agricultural workers’ exposure. According to the analysis, the Brazilian database contained 17 confirmed poisonings last year in which Dormex was named.
The issue touches on a difference in regulation. European companies may produce some products that are not authorised for agricultural use in the EU for export to countries where they are legal. Companies say that countries make their own assessments of risk and that their products are safe when used according to the label. The analysis alone cannot establish that European products caused all the reported health problems.
Also show the region and a close-up
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- European pesticide products were named in Brazilian health reports.
- Some of the substances involved are not authorised for agricultural use in the EU.
- The reports do not prove in each case that a product was the cause.
- Companies dispute the reliability and interpretation of some of the data.
Left
Arguments A substance considered too risky for agricultural use in Europe should not be exported and thereby expose workers and local residents elsewhere.
Values Health protection, global responsibility and the precautionary principle.
Consequences An export ban could limit risks, but could also lead to trade disputes and raise the question of how farmers in other countries would obtain affordable alternatives.
Centre
Arguments Better registration, independent oversight and international agreements are needed before far-reaching trade bans are introduced.
Values Evidence, proportionality and workable regulation.
Consequences Better data could make policy more targeted, but would not immediately resolve the differences between European and Brazilian authorisation rules.
Right
Arguments Countries should be able to decide for themselves which products suit their crops, climate and farming practices, provided that products are used according to the rules.
Values National authority, freedom of choice and economic development.
Consequences Wider access to products could support agricultural production, but leaves responsibility with national regulators and users.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The text uses the figures and classifications described in the analysis. Causal claims have been qualified because the sources themselves point to uncertainties in the registration.
- confirmed European pesticide companies were named in 1,605 of 2,857 reports involving a recognisable product. — This is stated in the analysis described by The Guardian. source
- confirmed Of the 2,857 reports, 1,420 were classified as confirmed poisoning and 1,108 as exposure. — The classifications are mentioned in the source article. source
- confirmed Reglone was named 44 times, including in four reports involving a death. — This is stated in the analysis as published by The Guardian. source
Editor's note
The figures come from a journalistic analysis of Brazilian health reports. The reports show associations and registration, but do not prove a causal link in each individual case.Sources
More on this in Dutch media
- AD — „pesticiden brazilië”
- de Volkskrant — „pesticiden brazilië”
- RTL Nieuws — „pesticiden brazilië”