Texel PAS reporters gain prospect of nature permit
A provincial analysis indicates that nature restoration on Texel could make permits possible again, but approval is not guaranteed.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
All eleven agricultural PAS reporters on Texel are expected to be able to apply for a nature permit. A two-year pilot by the province of North Holland concludes that nature restoration and lower nitrogen deposition make permits possible on the island.
The province presented the results of its pilot on Wednesday concerning the Duinen en Lage Land Natura 2000 area on Texel. According to the analysis, nature there has improved in recent years as a result of management measures, and nitrogen no longer poses an obstacle to permits there under certain conditions.
PAS reporters are agricultural businesses that were allowed to submit a notification under the former Nitrogen Approach Programme. According to that interpretation, following a 2019 ruling by the Council of State, they still had to obtain a nature permit. Many businesses were consequently left in legal uncertainty.
According to Nieuwe Oogst, the analysis was prepared with external experts, including ecologist Reinoud Kleijberg. In a small part of the area, nitrogen deposition is still above the critical load value, according to Nieuwe Oogst. The province wants to address this with additional measures, such as grazing, mowing and removing grass, and restoring open sand.
The permits have not yet been granted. In the coming weeks, the province will work with the eleven businesses on applications that are expected to be made available for public inspection from December. Each application will be assessed separately to determine whether the conditions have been met.
An important condition is that nitrogen emissions do not increase and that the nature restoration measures continue. The outcome is therefore primarily an administrative and ecological prospect, not a general exemption for agriculture or other projects in the Netherlands.
The pilot is nevertheless relevant beyond Texel. The province describes the island as one of the first sensitive nature areas where permits again appear possible through offsetting. Whether the approach will withstand legal scrutiny and can be applied elsewhere remains to be seen during the public-inspection period and in any objection and appeal proceedings.
Also show where in Europe and in the world
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- A provincial pilot concludes that nature restoration and nitrogen measures make permits possible on Texel.
- Eleven PAS reporters can prepare an application.
- Permits will be assessed individually and nitrogen emissions must not increase.
- Part of the area remains above the critical load value.
Left
Arguments Nature restoration must demonstrably come first, and permits must not be used to conceal a structural breach of nitrogen limits. The approach is defensible only if restoration measures are legally secured and funded for the long term.
Values Nature protection, precaution and intergenerational responsibility.
Consequences Farmers gain a prospect, but if restoration falls short, the granting of permits must be capable of being restricted or reversed.
Centre
Arguments The pilot combines restoration with individual assessment and external review. This offers an institutional route out of uncertainty, provided the underlying analysis proves transparent, verifiable and legally robust.
Values Legal certainty, practicality and balance between nature and the economy.
Consequences Texel could become a useful practical example, but only if objection procedures and monitoring confirm the approach.
Right
Arguments Entrepreneurs who operated for years with a notification should receive legal and business certainty as quickly as possible when nature has in fact recovered. From this perspective, an area-specific approach is better than national paralysis.
Values Property, entrepreneurship and predictable regulation.
Consequences Faster permits could save businesses, but new emissions or inadequate oversight could cause renewed legal uncertainty later.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
Reporting by NH Nieuws and Nieuwe Oogst confirms the date, the eleven PAS reporters, the pilot and the conditions. The article clearly distinguishes between an analysis that offers a prospect and permits that have actually been granted.
- confirmed All eleven PAS reporters on Texel are expected to be able to apply for a nature permit. — This is stated in Nieuwe Oogst’s reporting on the provincial pilot. source
- confirmed The permits have not yet been granted and are expected to be made available for public inspection from December. — Mentioned by Nieuwe Oogst. source
- confirmed In a small part of the area, nitrogen deposition is still above the critical load value. — Mentioned in Nieuwe Oogst’s description of the analysis. source
- confirmed A permit is not automatically guaranteed. — NH Nieuws reports that each application will be assessed separately and that emissions must not increase. source
Editor's note
The analysis of nature restoration and nitrogen loading is a new provincial assessment. Permits have not yet been granted; legal robustness, objections and individual assessment remain uncertain.Sources
- 'Stikstof geen gevaar meer': Texelse agrariërs kunnen weer vergunning aanvragen — NH Nieuws
- Alle elf PAS-melders op Texel kunnen vergunning verwachten — Nieuwe Oogst
- PAS-melders — Provincie Noord-Holland
More on this in Dutch media
- de Volkskrant — „texel pas-melders”
- NU.nl — „texel pas-melders”
- De Telegraaf — „texel pas-melders”