US plans seabed auction despite legal action
An auction of 20-year mining leases for two areas near American Samoa is planned, while a judge criticised the environmental assessment.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
The United States has scheduled an auction on Thursday for two large areas of seabed near American Samoa. The move is intended to provide access to underwater minerals, but faces legal objections and concerns about ecosystems and fishing.
The two areas cover a combined 31.5 million acres, equivalent to about 127,000 square kilometres. The leases would last 20 years and target deposits containing nickel, cobalt and manganese, among other materials used in batteries and other technology.
According to S&P Global, the minimum bid is $3 million per area. The auction does not, however, automatically give companies the right to begin mining: actual extraction would require additional environmental assessments and permits.
The Trump administration presents extraction as part of a strategy for critical minerals and reduced dependence on foreign supply chains, particularly those in which China holds a strong position. The US ministry stresses that environmental assessment and consultation with local communities remain part of the process.
Opponents in American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands fear harm to marine habitats, fisheries and areas of cultural importance. The proposed sites are near protected marine monuments and in a region where residents depend heavily on the ocean.
AP describes legal uncertainty after a judge ruled on Monday that the federal government had not fully assessed the effects of a lease under the Endangered Species Act. According to AP, the auction was still on the agenda on Wednesday; it is unclear whether it has since produced a winner.
The news is therefore chiefly about a policy choice, not mining that has begun. Commercial deep-sea mining has not yet started anywhere in the world. If extraction does take place, the question of its effects on ecosystems will remain.
Also show the region and a close-up
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- The US government has scheduled an auction of seabed leases near American Samoa.
- The areas may contain critical minerals, but extraction requires additional permits.
- A judge has criticised the lease’s environmental assessment.
Left
Arguments Emphasises that ocean ecosystems and local communities must not be sacrificed for resource policy, and that alternatives, recycling and strict international oversight are needed first.
Values Environmental protection, climate justice and the participation of local communities.
Consequences Fears irreversible damage to biodiversity, fisheries and culturally important areas.
Centre
Arguments Accepts research into critical minerals only under strict environmental rules, transparent permitting and demonstrable involvement of the islands.
Values Scientific rigour, the rule of law and a balance between supply security and nature.
Consequences Would allow the process to continue where the law permits, but make extraction conditional on independent assessment and monitoring.
Right
Arguments Emphasises that access to domestic resources could strengthen US industry and national security and reduce dependence on China.
Values Economic resilience, national security and sovereignty over natural resources.
Consequences Fears that excessive delays would weaken technological development and the US position in strategic minerals.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The text carefully distinguishes between a lease auction and actual mining. The size, duration, minerals and legal uncertainty have been checked against AP and S&P Global.
- confirmed The US scheduled an auction on 19 November for two seabed areas near American Samoa. — AP and S&P Global state the auction date and location. source
- confirmed The areas cover a combined 31.5 million acres. — S&P Global explicitly gives the combined size. source
- confirmed The leases last 20 years and have a minimum bid of $3 million per area. — These conditions appear in S&P Global’s publication. source
- confirmed A judge ruled that the effects on protected species had not been fully assessed. — AP describes Monday’s ruling and the legal uncertainty surrounding the auction. source
- confirmed Commercial deep-sea mining has not yet started anywhere in the world. — AP reports that no commercial operations have yet begun worldwide. source
Editor's note
The auction and the size of the lease areas have been confirmed by AP and S&P Global. The sources do not yet confirm a winner or actual mining; the legal consequences of the judge’s ruling are uncertain.Sources
More on this in Dutch media
- NRC — „diepzeemijnbouw amerikaans-samoa”
- NOS — „diepzeemijnbouw amerikaans-samoa”
- Het Parool — „diepzeemijnbouw amerikaans-samoa”