Consumentenbond warns of growing smartphone requirement at banks
Bank customers are offered fewer and fewer alternatives to banking apps, while 86 per cent of respondents want a fully fledged option without an app.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
Banks are increasingly directing customers towards their smartphone apps for payments and other services. The Consumentenbond warns that this is excluding especially people without a smartphone or with limited digital skills.
The immediate trigger is dozens of complaints received by the Consumentenbond about ING. Since October, customers have had to confirm payments via Wero, the successor to iDEAL, using the banking app. The ING scanner is no longer accepted as an alternative. ASN Bank also wants to make a banking app compulsory for Wero payments from 2028.
According to the Consumentenbond, Triodos Bank is gradually phasing out its identifier, a device that customers use to log in and confirm payments and transfers. The organisation reports that new customers no longer receive an identifier, while existing customers are granted an exception only if they specifically ask for one. Some services, such as taking out a fixed-term savings deposit, are already available exclusively through the app, according to the Consumentenbond.
In a survey of 3,830 panel members, 86 per cent said they wanted a fully fledged alternative to apps for important services. Banking came first, followed by government services and healthcare. Twenty-three per cent said they had at some point been unable to arrange something because a smartphone was required. The survey measures the participants’ experiences and views; it is not a survey of all Dutch bank customers.
The vulnerability is not limited to people with few digital skills. The Consumentenbond refers to a finding by De Nederlandsche Bank in 2023 that 2.6 million people in the Netherlands cannot manage all their banking independently. Professor of digital inequality Alexander van Deursen says the problem mainly arises when people no longer have a genuine choice between devices and ways of receiving services.
At ABN Amro and Rabobank, customers can still arrange ordinary banking matters without a smartphone, according to the Consumentenbond. European rules could limit compulsory smartphone use for payments from 2028 or 2029, the organisation says. Until then, banks largely decide for themselves which alternatives they offer. The heart of the debate is therefore not whether apps are useful, but whether access to a bank account may depend on a single device and platform.
Also show where in Europe and in the world
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- ING has used the banking app as a confirmation method for Wero payments since October 2026.
- The Consumentenbond surveyed 3,830 panel members; 86 per cent wanted a fully fledged alternative to apps.
- According to the Consumentenbond, European rules intended to protect alternatives are expected from 2028 or 2029.
Left
Arguments Important services such as banking should remain accessible without requiring people to use a smartphone, app or commercial platform.
Values Equal access, public services and protection of vulnerable groups.
Consequences Banks would have to incur additional costs for scanners, telephone assistance and physical alternatives, but exclusion could be reduced.
Centre
Arguments Apps are efficient and can be secure, but banks should retain at least one reliable alternative for essential actions.
Values Accessibility, proportionality and practicality.
Consequences A transition period with clear minimum standards could allow innovation without abruptly depriving customers of access.
Right
Arguments Banks should retain room to choose modern, well-secured systems; customers can move to another bank if they consider an alternative important.
Values Market forces, efficiency, personal responsibility and security.
Consequences Overly strict rules could slow innovation and saddle banks with expensive duplicate systems, but reputational and liability risks would remain.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The current banking measures and survey figures appear in the Consumentenbond publications used. The text clearly distinguishes between research results, bank policy and expected European regulation.
- confirmed ING has required customers since October 2026 to confirm Wero payments using the banking app. — Mentioned in the Consumentenbond’s current publication. source
- confirmed Eighty-six per cent of 3,830 panel members want a fully fledged alternative to apps. — The survey data appear in the publication. source
- confirmed Twenty-three per cent had at some point been unable to arrange something because a smartphone was required. — Mentioned in both publications used. source
- confirmed European rules could limit compulsory smartphone use for payments from 2028 or 2029. — The Consumentenbond describes this as the expected Payment Services Regulation. source
Editor's note
The survey, complaints and banking details come from the Consumentenbond. The figures say something about the panel members surveyed and do not automatically apply to all bank customers; independent confirmation of the survey results is lacking.Sources
- Banken dringen steeds meer hun bankapps op aan klanten — Consumentenbond
- Geen app, geen toegang — Consumentenbond
More on this in Dutch media
- AD — „bankieren smartphone”
- RTL Nieuws — „bankieren smartphone”
- FD — „bankieren smartphone”