South Korea’s ruling party seeks to impeach chief justice
The Democratic Party links the move to a controversial ruling on the 2024 declaration of martial law.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
South Korea’s ruling Democratic Party decided on Friday to begin impeachment proceedings against Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae. The party intends to submit the motion this year, a day after the Supreme Court partially overturned an earlier conviction of former prime minister Han Duck-soo.
The party took the decision during a meeting of its lawmakers. According to party spokesperson Jeon Eun-su, the Democratic Party faults Cho, among other things, for the way the Supreme Court responded to the declaration of martial law in December 2024. The party also cites a ruling on the election case against President Lee Jae-myung and the alleged improper use of official funds as grounds for the proceedings.
The Democratic Party holds 161 of the 300 seats in the National Assembly. This means it can pass an impeachment motion on its own, according to Yonhap. That does not mean Cho automatically loses his position: after a parliamentary vote, the subsequent constitutional procedure would be decisive.
The decision follows the ruling on Han Duck-soo. On Thursday, the Supreme Court overturned a 15-year prison sentence and referred the case back to the appeals court. The judges ruled that it had not been sufficiently proven that Han had intended to overthrow the Constitution before the declaration of martial law.
The Supreme Court did uphold other parts of the case. According to AP, this included the finding that Han was involved after the declaration in discussions about cutting off water and electricity supplies to critical media outlets, and that he had lied under oath and forged and destroyed a proclamation. The appeals court must reconsider the remanded case.
The ruling prompted accusations within the ruling party that the judiciary had failed to address the political crisis surrounding former president Yoon Suk Yeol adequately. The martial law declared on 3 December 2024 was ended within hours after lawmakers rejected the measure. Yoon was later removed from office; legal proceedings over his actions are still under way.
The proposed impeachment once again makes relations between the executive, parliament and the judiciary a focus of the political struggle. The party says it wants to protect the independence of the rule of law from abuses of power. From the perspective of judicial independence, the impeachment attempt could be seen as a parliamentary majority punishing a judge for an unwelcome ruling. The party wants to submit the motion this year; it is not yet clear when a vote would take place.
Also show the region and a close-up
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- The ruling Democratic Party has decided that it wants to submit an impeachment motion against Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae.
- The party cites, among other things, the Supreme Court’s response to martial law, an election case involving President Lee Jae-myung and the alleged improper use of official funds as grounds.
- The Supreme Court referred the case against former prime minister Han Duck-soo back to the appeals court after partially overturning a 15-year prison sentence.
- According to Yonhap, the Democratic Party holds 161 of the 300 seats in the National Assembly.
Left
Arguments A left-wing approach emphasises that judicial institutions must be held accountable when, in this view, they offered insufficient resistance to an unconstitutional seizure of power. The ruling on Han may then be seen as grounds for holding the judicial leadership politically and institutionally accountable.
Values Democratic oversight, protection of civil rights and rejection of authoritarian use of power.
Consequences Supporters fear that failing to intervene would further undermine confidence in the rule of law and make future seizures of power less difficult.
Centre
Arguments An institutional approach distinguishes between criticism of a ruling and the impeachment of a judge. It would first seek to have the legal grounds, the evidence and the normal constitutional procedure reviewed.
Values Separation of powers, procedural care and continuity of state institutions.
Consequences A careful procedure could limit escalation, but prolonged uncertainty could put pressure on the functioning of the judiciary and public confidence.
Right
Arguments A right-wing approach emphasises that judges must be able to rule independently without parliamentary punishment for a controversial decision. In this view, the impeachment attempt could resemble political retaliation by a ruling majority.
Values Judicial independence, institutional restraint and protection against majority power.
Consequences Supporters fear a precedent: future majorities could threaten judges whenever rulings are politically unwelcome.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The article’s central claim has been confirmed by Yonhap, with AP providing an independent source for the trigger and legal context. The text clearly distinguishes between the party’s intention, the earlier judicial ruling and the still-uncertain next steps.
- confirmed On 20 November, the ruling Democratic Party decided to impeach Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae. — Yonhap reports that the party adopted the plan as official party policy during a meeting of lawmakers. source
- confirmed The party wants to submit the impeachment motion before the end of the year. — This is stated explicitly in the Yonhap report. source
- confirmed The Democratic Party holds 161 of the 300 seats. — Yonhap gives both figures and concludes that the party can pass the motion on its own. source
- confirmed The Supreme Court overturned Han Duck-soo’s conviction and referred the case to the appeals court. — This is confirmed by Yonhap and AP. source
- confirmed The impeachment proceedings do not automatically lead to Cho losing his position. — This is a general procedural explanation; the article presents the subsequent constitutional outcome as still open. source
Editor's note
What is certain is that the ruling Democratic Party adopted the impeachment proceedings against Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae as party policy on 20 November and wants to submit them this year. The precise parliamentary timetable and the subsequent constitutional outcome remain unknown.Sources
- Ruling party formally decides to seek impeachment of chief justice — Yonhap News Agency
- South Korea’s top court overturns Han Duck-soo conviction in martial law case — Associated Press
- Top court overturns 15-yr prison term for ex-PM Han over martial law role — Yonhap News Agency