Cabinet rewrites box 3 after fresh Lower House criticism
The Council of Ministers has approved an amending bill intended to spare small savers and investors.
The cabinet is once again making changes to the tax on wealth in box 3. Prime Minister Rob Jetten acknowledges that many people can no longer follow the rapid policy shifts.
On Friday, the Council of Ministers approved an amending bill to the proposal for a tax on actual returns. The cabinet wants it to align as closely as possible with a capital gains tax. The Council of State has been asked to provide an expedited opinion on the amending bill.
The immediate cause is criticism in the Lower House of the proposed funding package. Small savers and investors could initially have been hit harder than previously announced. Minister Eelco Heinen has therefore said that this group must be spared in the new funding package.
According to the cabinet, the amended approach should be able to secure sufficient support in both Houses. That support is not yet certain. The government is in a minority position and depends on opposition parties for important parts of the Tax Plan.
The precise form of the funding package has not yet been finalised. In recent days, various options have been mentioned, including changes relating to paper gifts and inheritance tax. The cabinet says it wants to discuss those proposals further with the Lower House.
The debate also affects the timetable. Under the current agenda, the Lower House is due to vote on the Tax Plan on 12 November. Delays to the legislation could affect the planned introduction of a new box 3 system, but the final timetable depends on parliamentary decision-making.
The cabinet is presenting the amending bill as a definitive solution, but politically the matter is not over. The Council of State, the Lower House and the Senate must first consider the amended proposals.
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- The cabinet has approved an amending bill for box 3.
- The government wants to spare small savers and investors in the funding package.
- The parliamentary process and precise financial details have not yet been finalised.
Left
Arguments Wealth may be taxed more heavily than labour, but small savers should not be treated as though they were large wealth holders. The government should primarily ask the strongest shoulders to bear the burden.
Values Redistribution, ability to pay and protecting households with little financial leeway.
Consequences A more progressive wealth tax could raise revenue, but requires clear boundaries and workable rules.
Centre
Arguments The tax must reflect actual returns, be legally robust and remain workable for citizens and the Tax Administration.
Values Legal certainty, workability and budgetary stability.
Consequences A gradual introduction with compensation for small fortunes could increase public support, but would make the system more complex.
Right
Arguments Savers and investors should not be repeatedly caught off guard by rapidly changing plans. Taxing wealth can discourage saving, entrepreneurship and investment.
Values Property, predictability and economic incentives.
Consequences A limited levy could reduce capital flight and avoidance, but may generate less revenue.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The procedural steps and statements were checked against the Dutch government and NOS. The text makes clear which parts are not yet final.
- confirmed The Council of Ministers approved an amending bill for box 3 on 2 October. — This is stated in Prime Minister Jetten’s transcribed statement. source
- confirmed Small savers and investors would be spared in the funding package. — Jetten refers to Minister Heinen’s undertaking. source
- confirmed Under the current timetable, the Lower House will vote on the Tax Plan on 12 November. — Mentioned in NOS reporting. source