Pillay responds to Nobel Prize with a joke
The South African jurist heard the news in Nuremberg, where she was greeted with applause.
There is news on this story (Friday, 9 October 2026, 16:45): US imposes new sanctions on ICC
Follow-up to: Navi Pillay awarded Nobel Peace Prize Friday, 9 October 2026, 11:44
Navi Pillay publicly responded to her Nobel Peace Prize for the first time on Friday. Colleagues in Nuremberg greeted the announcement with applause; Pillay responded, among other things, with a joke about US President Donald Trump.
Pillay heard the news during a meeting on international law in Nuremberg. According to international media, the Nobel Committee initially could not reach her. In the courtroom where the trials of Nazi leaders took place after the Second World War, those present cheered her after the prize was announced.
The 85-year-old jurist said she first wanted to check whether the report was really true. In a brief response, she joked that she might share the prize with Trump if the applause grew even louder. Those present shared the remark on social media, and it quickly attracted international attention.
The Nobel Committee awarded the prize for Pillay’s commitment to peace and international law. According to the committee, she contributed to the prosecution of war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide. Pillay previously worked as a judge at international courts and was the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
The award therefore also carries a political dimension. Pillay led a UN commission of inquiry that accused Israel of genocide in Gaza. Israel rejects that accusation and has criticised the Nobel selection. That criticism concerns the assessment of the investigation and the question of whether Pillay acted impartially enough.
The United Nations and human rights organisations, by contrast, welcomed the prize as support for international justice. They see Pillay’s career as an example of a legal system in which powerful states and leaders can also be held to account. The reactions show that it is difficult to separate the person, her legal work and the political consequences of her reports.
The new response changes nothing about the earlier award, but it does make clear how the prize is being received: as recognition of international law by her supporters and as a political judgement on Israel by her critics. In her first public remarks, Pillay herself mainly emphasised the importance of the rule of law that she says she defends.
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- Pillay received the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize.
- She led a UN commission of inquiry into Israel and the Palestinian territories.
- Israel rejects the genocide allegations and criticised the prize.
Left
Arguments The prize confirms that international justice and human rights must remain guiding principles even in wartime. Criticism from states affected by investigations must not undermine independent accountability.
Values Universal human rights, equality before the law and the protection of civilians.
Consequences The prize may give victims and international institutions recognition, but could also further intensify diplomatic divisions.
Centre
Arguments The prize can be seen as recognition of a long legal career, while the methods and conclusions of individual UN investigations should be assessed separately. International institutions need credibility as well as verifiable procedures.
Values Institutional independence, evidence and the rule of law.
Consequences A careful assessment can strengthen confidence in international justice, but requires restraint regarding political conclusions about the prize itself.
Right
Arguments International legal institutions must not give the impression that they are settling political conflicts without sufficient balance or oversight. The choice of Pillay may be interpreted as one-sided criticism of Israel and as the politicisation of the Nobel Prize.
Values National sovereignty, procedural neutrality and distrust of the concentration of international power.
Consequences The prize may further weaken support for international investigations among Israel and its allies.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The response and the political interpretation are based on AP, the Nobel Committee, UN information and a publicly available video response. Controversial claims have been attributed to the parties concerned.
- confirmed Navi Pillay heard the news during a meeting in Nuremberg. — Reported by the Associated Press. source
- confirmed Pillay responded with a joke about sharing the prize with Donald Trump. — The video response was described by Al Jazeera. source
- confirmed The Nobel Committee awarded the prize for Pillay’s commitment to peace and international law. — Stated in the Nobel Committee’s official press release. source
- confirmed Israel has criticised the Nobel selection. — Reported by AP and in the response from Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. source
- confirmed Pillay led a UN commission that accused Israel of genocide in Gaza. — AP describes the commission’s finding and Israel’s denial. source
Editor's note
The prize, the location of Pillay’s response, the applause and the various reactions have been confirmed by official and independent sources. The accusations concerning Gaza have been attributed as positions and investigation findings, rather than presented as undisputed fact.Sources
- Praise pours in for Nobel Peace Prize laureate Navi Pillay even as Israel criticizes selection — Associated Press
- Nobel Peace Prize for 2026 — Norwegian Nobel Committee
- HC Reaction to Navi Pillay receiving the Nobel peace prize — United Nations Geneva
- Is it April fool’s? Navi Pillay reacts to Nobel Peace Prize news — Al Jazeera
The story so far
- Friday, 9 October 2026, 11:44 Navi Pillay awarded Nobel Peace Prize
- Friday, 9 October 2026, 15:44 Pillay responds to Nobel Prize with a joke (this article)
- Friday, 9 October 2026, 16:45 US imposes new sanctions on ICC