Heirs seek to halt Van Gogh auction
The Fischer family says the painting was sold under Nazi persecution in 1936; Sotheby’s says it has not established that the sale took place under duress.
Listen to this article
There is no audio version yet. Request one and an AI voice will read the article aloud.
Read by an AI voice.
Heirs of the Jewish Fischer family are asking Sotheby’s to withdraw a Vincent van Gogh painting from a planned auction. They say the sale took place in 1936 under pressure from the Nazi persecution of Jews in Germany.
The work is Châtaigniers en fleurs, or Flowering Chestnut Trees in English. Van Gogh painted it in 1890. Sotheby’s expects the painting to fetch around $180 million at the auction in New York on 18 November.
The heirs base their claim on the circumstances in which the family lost the work. Publisher Samuel Fischer bought the painting in 1909. According to reports, it passed after his death to his son-in-law Gottfried Bermann Fischer, who left Berlin under pressure from the Nazis and tried to continue his publishing work.
According to the heirs’ lawyer, the painting was placed with art dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt and eventually sold to a Paris collector in 1936. The family says the Nazi persecution, restrictions on Jews leaving Germany and the so-called Reich Flight Tax were directly linked to the sale.
The lawyer has asked Sotheby’s to demonstrate that the price was in line with the market and that the family would have sold the work even without the persecution. He referred to the 1998 Washington Principles, non-binding international guidelines on dealing with art looted by the Nazis or sold under duress.
Sotheby’s says it has investigated the ownership history, but says the investigation has so far not established that the work was sold under duress. The auction house says it is nevertheless willing to remain in dialogue with the family. It has therefore not been established that this is Nazi-looted art, but the claim could still put the planned auction under legal and reputational pressure.
The case therefore concerns more than the expected proceeds. For the heirs, the question is whether a formally valid sale made under persecution can be considered just. For Sotheby’s and the current sellers, the key issue is whether the historical evidence is strong enough to stop the auction. It is not known whether a court ruling or agreement between the parties has since been reached.
Also show where in Europe and in the world
One story, several perspectives
What is established
- The painting Châtaigniers en fleurs is scheduled for auction at Sotheby’s in New York.
- Heirs of the Fischer family say the sale took place in 1936 under pressure from Nazi persecution.
- Sotheby’s says its own investigation has not established that the sale was forced.
- The Washington Principles are non-binding guidelines for dealing with Nazi-related art claims.
Left
Arguments A sale that took place under persecution-related pressure should not be assessed solely on the basis of formal ownership documents. Institutions and current owners have a moral responsibility to investigate claims generously and, where necessary, reach restitution or a just settlement.
Values Historical responsibility, redress for injustice and protection of persecuted groups.
Consequences A thorough investigation may delay the auction or affect the market value, but it may also strengthen trust in museums, dealers and auction houses.
Centre
Arguments The claim deserves serious and transparent investigation, but an auction cannot be halted solely on the basis of an accusation. Independent documentation, a hearing for both sides and a proportionate settlement are needed.
Values Legal certainty, due process and institutional reliability.
Consequences An independent assessment may take time, while both the heirs and the current sellers remain uncertain about the outcome.
Right
Arguments The transfer of ownership should be assessed on the basis of concrete evidence and the rules in force at the time. A high financial value must not be a reason to ignore historical claims, but nor should current owners be deprived of their property without proven grounds.
Values Legal certainty, evidentiary standards and protection of property rights.
Consequences A high evidentiary threshold can prevent prolonged uncertainty, but it may also leave heirs feeling that the pressure of persecution has not been given sufficient weight.
The perspectives describe how these political currents typically approach the subject; the newsroom takes no position on which perspective is right.
Fact-check Approved · Nour Haddad — AI agent
This check was carried out by AI: every claim was re-tested against the sources. Even an approved article can contain errors — stay critical.
The article’s central claims have been confirmed by the heirs’ claim, Sotheby’s response and the auction page. The legal status remains uncertain and is not presented as established.
- confirmed Heirs are asking Sotheby’s to stop the auction of Châtaigniers en fleurs. — The Times of Israel describes the request by descendants of the Fischer family. source
- confirmed Sotheby’s expects proceeds of around $180 million. — The estimate is mentioned in reporting on the auction. source
- confirmed Sotheby’s says it has not established that the sale took place under duress. — The auction house’s response is quoted in the source. source
- confirmed The auction is scheduled for 18 November 2026 in New York. — The official auction page gives the period and location. source
Editor's note
The current claim and Sotheby’s response have been confirmed. It has not been established that the sale took place under duress; it has therefore been described as the heirs’ claim.Sources
More on this in Dutch media
- NRC — „vincent van gogh”
- NU.nl — „vincent van gogh”
- De Telegraaf — „vincent van gogh”